Automation & Control / Water/Waste

Modular Approach to Water Processing Control & Automation

"Lego" inspired control concept from Festo creates a better fitting, economical method to automate this critical utility

By Steven E. Kuehn, Editor in Chief

Almost anyone can recognize the practicality associated with the concept of modularity. To the many engineers who busy themselves designing, engineering and constructing complex pharma processing systems, the idea of managing such complexity by breaking it down into standardized subsystems and components is a well understood and pragmatic approach to system design. According to Festo, such is the case with automation and control. Modular systems, say Festo, speed up the design and configuration of automated processes, lower overall costs, and make a process like water filtration more flexible and therefore better at adapting to new operational requirements and responsive to market demands.

"This approach represents a fundamental shift in the design and engineering requirements for water filtration applications," says Craig Correia, head of Process Automation at Festo. "Flexibility is achieved through consistent modularization, i.e., dividing a complete plant into functional units. "These functional modules are combined to create the automated filtration system. Water filtration plants built on these functional elements can be extended almost indefinitely by adding modules, thus enabling immediate adaptation to market and filtration requirements."

According to Festo, the design and engineering of a given process is precisely tailored to the respective task, whether for producing a specific product in X units per time unit or to generate the throughput of a specific substance in X quantity per time unit. As a whole, the mechanical design of the plant is geared toward meeting specifications and assuring the required performance data over its projected lifecycle.

Correa explains that the corresponding automation is configured using management systems comprised of process-specific (control) components, operating and monitoring stations as well as engineering stations. The entire process is centrally controlled by a single management system.

SPEED TO MARKET IMPERATIVE DRIVES DEMAND FOR FLEXIBILITY
Festo maintains that markets are increasingly demanding shorter product development cycles, particularly in the small and large molecule pharmaceutical industry segments. The result? Correa says it has prompted a fundamental shift in the design and engineering requirements for process plants of all types including water filtration. He explains the necessary flexibility is something that is available now and achieved through consistent modularization, that is dividing a complete plant into its functional units. "These production modules can be combined to produce specific process plants," says Correa, "which can be extended almost indefinitely by adding modules, thus enabling immediate adaptation to market and production requirements. Capacity is increased by numbering up instead of scaling up."

The ability to temporarily sideline production modules from the current production process, notes Correa, is another aspect of the concept's inherent flexibility that will have a positive impact on operations and managing maintenance, equipment change-outs and other similar tasks.

Most water filtration plant designs include pipes, pumps, valves, tanks, filter modules and sensors. Correa says the required components for actuating the field devices are installed in a control cabinet. Valve terminals, such as a remote I/O system with integrated pneumatic section, are connected to a central controller with visualization (management system) via a fieldbus. Plants of this type, he says, can be easily modularized by breaking down the process into subprocesses and defining a module for each sub-process with all the mechanical and automation components required for stand alone operation. For a water/waste water plant, key or critical modules would likely include its pumps, filtration modules and the clean-in-place system.

Builders find themselves engineering a skid based on a customer's spec," says Correa. "So each one is different. They might be able to cut and paste previous designs, like the control cabinet or skid layout, and just scale it. But this adds to lead time, and as a result adds cost." In an ideal world, explains Correa, builders would have a design that is scalable, not by changing the design, but by plugging a few modules in parallel. "Because even when they change the design," Carrea notes, "they have to purchase a fabricated frame, etc., which is unique. The concept here, which some OEMs are doing, is to create smaller solutions which can be mounted easily in parallel as more throughput is needed and have specific functions for each. When the spec specifies the volume and the filtration levels, they can expand both the capacity (parallel modules) and filtration types (modules in series)."

Figure 1 diagrams a typical design for a water filtration plant with valves, pumps, tanks, filter modules, sensors and pipes. Components required for actuating the field devices are installed in a control cabinet, and a valve terminal as a remote I/O system with integrated pneumatic section is connected to a central controller with visualization (management system) via a fieldbus.

Plants of this type can be easily modularized by breaking down the process into subprocesses and defining a module for each subprocess with all the mechanical and automation components required for standalone operation.

Correa says Festo's concept modularizes automation components: "The control cabinet components and the "central intelligence" (the application software for the process) are divided up so that the modules each have their own controllers, remote I/O components and pneumatic actuators." (See Figure 2)

Festo explains each module provides its specific functionality discretely at a data interface, that is, after the modules are interconnected to form a process plant, characteristics like operating mode, status, process measurements, alerts, etc., can be read/written in order to realize the functionality of the plant as a whole. (See Figure 3) "A process management system is required to coordinate the module functionalities in the complete system, that is, to manage the process," says Correa. "Unlike traditional management systems, this system has a greatly reduced range of functions since the process-specific control functions are realized in the standalone modules."

  • Modular automation and control supports a plant engineer's pursuit of process modularity where any configuration to be assembled can be by adding modules of identical construction and function (See Figure 4), thus allowing a numbering up expansion strategy instead of scaling up (See Figure 5).

According to Festo, the modularization solution shown in Figure 5 has been consistently implemented for water filtration plants and can be applied similarly for processes and plants supporting pharmaceutical manufacturing operations. Festo explains that it is not just plant operators who are likely to benefit from modular automation's flexibility when it comes to adapting plant sizes to different production requirements, but will also benefit vendors and solutions providers who are striving to introduce the efficiency, flexibility and economy of modularity into the plant and process systems they engineer for their Pharma customers.

  • Modules are precisely defined units with clear functionality.
  • Modules are equipped with their specific application software, which reduces the respective software complexity.
  • Modules are easy to change/extend in terms of their (clear) functionality.
  • Modules can be manufactured in small series and fully tested prior to delivery.
  • Customized complete systems are assembled from different modules of identical construction (numbering up).
  • Modules are programmed using CODESYS (as per IEC 61131-3, no license costs), i.e., independence when selecting the automation hardware.

"In the context of 'Internet of Things'" and based on the NAMUR recommendation NE 148," concludes Correa, "modular automation will effect a fundamental shift in the design and engineering of process plants." Modularization will not be possible to the same extent for all industry segments or every process, Correa explains, "However, the technical design process for each plant should include a review and assessment of whether modular concepts can be applied so both the plant operator and plant manufacturer can benefit from the associated advantages."